How to Optimize Your Time Management

Get Inspired

Powerful insights, fresh perspectives, time-saving tricks and golden nuggets distilled into a weekly digest delivered straight to your inbox

Fix Your Board

Are you ready to stop wasting time on ineffective board meetings? Are you ready to focus, instead, on what will actually move the needle for your nonprofit?

Join me for a value-packed session on how to re-organize your Board to transform their impact, in 5 easy steps.

Get More Staff

If you’re constantly trying to do more, never feel like there’s enough hours in the day and rarely get to be strategic in your role because you’re stuck in the weeds of running your nonprofit, not directing it (yes, I see you) ... You probably need more staff!!

Join my upcoming training on The 4 Part Framework For Staffing Up!

Make More Impact

Discover how to reclaim your valuable time and get laser-focused on the strategies that will really move the needle for your nonprofit with my signature system, The Impact Method™️. If your days feel like a game of Whack-a-Mole and you’re exhausted by the relentlessness of it all (and feel like this is NOT what you signed up for), this is for you.

Apply for your invitation to a special VIP Training "How To Reclaim Your Time... and Get Laser-Focused On The Strategies That Will Really Move The Needle For Your Nonprofit"

Operations & Capacity

How to Optimize Your Time Management

What do you do when everything is urgent and important and you can’t seem to get ahead of your to-do list? Let’s talk about time management.

For most of us, time management is a constant struggle.

Rather than managing our tasks, responsibilities, and time commitments, WE are the ones being managed.

Everything is urgent. Everything is important. And we cannot seem to get ahead of our to-do lists.

In this article, I'm going to talk about some simple tips and tricks to help you get more time back in your day and regain a sense of control over your work life.

Let’s start with The Eisenhower Matrix.

1. The Eisenhower Matrix

Made famous by Stephen Covey, the Eisenhower Matrix is a helpful method to prioritize your tasks. The matrix consists of four quadrants.

Quadrant 1: Urgent and important things

Quadrant 2: Not urgent, but important things

Quadrant 3: Not important, but urgent things

Quadrant 4: Not important and not urgent things

The problem is, we end up always living in Quadrant 1.

Which quadrant do you live in? Are the majority of your tasks in one of these quadrants or are you more of a combination?

The goal quadrant, or the sweet spot, is to live in Quadrant 2.

In order to do this, we have to optimize three things: our What, How, and When.

2. Optimize your What

The first thing you really need to optimize is your What.

You actually need to change what you’re doing before you can change your When and How.

2.1. Zone of genius

A really helpful tool for optimizing your What is finding your zone of genius.

Your zone of genius encompasses all the things you do that you’re both good at and are energizing for you.

Your wheelhouse, your area of expertise, things that are up your alley.

For example, when I give webinars, I leave them more energized than when I started. I'm both good at them and they energize me. So webinars are in my zone of genius.

Here are a few tools you can use to get a better sense of your zone of genius:

2.2. Three buckets

I use these three buckets to break down my to-do list and further optimize my What. Make a list of everything that ends up on your plate and categorize each task into one of the following...

Bucket 1: Things that are in your zone of genius

Bucket 2: You can do it, but it doesn’t energize you

Bucket 3: Not your forte, you're either not good at these tasks or they’re draining to you

After you’ve put all of your tasks in one of these three buckets, we're going to work backwards.

We're going to take buckets 2 and 3 (the things that you can do, but don't energize you and the things that are not your forte) and we're going to start getting them off your plate.

This is the big hack. You actually have to do less to get out of Quadrant 1. Doing everything slows you down and keeps you focused solely on the urgent.

It's like a self-fulfilling prophecy. The more things you put on your plate in an effort to get out of Quadrant 1 actually keeps you in Quadrant 1.

So let’s talk about where we can put those tasks in buckets 2 and 3.

2.3. Off your plate

First of all, those things in bucket 3, those things that are not your forte? These must go at almost any cost.

If you're bad at something, it's probably better that it doesn't get done at all than for you to do it and be bad at it. Especially if you're already over capacity in your organization.

I would like to give you a gift. This is a fireproof trash can. You can put something in there and when everybody says, "oh hey, there's a fire over there" you can say, "yep, it's under control, I'm just letting it burn itself out.”

Let it go.

The next thing you can do, if you CAN’T just not do it, is to delegate it.

Delegating means getting somebody else to do it for you. Take those leftover things in buckets 2 and 3 and pass them off.

One of the things in bucket 2 for me was following up with people. I just don't love following up with people, but someone has to do it. So I hired an assistant who loves following up with people and she helps me get that done.

I took something that's in my bucket 3 and delegated it to somebody who would categorize that task in their zone of genius bucket.

That’s a pretty good trade.

3. Optimize your How

Whatever tasks are left on your plate should either be in your zone of genius or something that you can do, but doesn’t energize you. Now it’s time to optimize your How.

We’re going to systematize, automate, and simplify to improve these tasks.

Now, systematizing doesn't have to be automation, but automation is a great way to systematize something.

I used to spend a fair amount of time filing my paperwork. I work from home and my team is remote so I get the mail and am the only one who can do this task. It’s definitely not my zone of genius, and it doesn't really bring that much value.

So I simplified my filing system so that I only had three folders to put things into: bank accounts, bills and statements, and all other documents. By simplifying my routine I cut my filing time down to just a few minutes.

A technological example would be to use automation. Tools like Zapier can take so much off your plate by automatically doing things that you spend time doing yourself.

I use a tool called Cloze, which helps me (and my assistant) manage my email and follow up with people. It saves me a ton of time and energy because it's reminding me of those things, which also gives me peace of mind that nothing is falling through the cracks.

One thing to remember when creating automations is that if you automate a mistake, you're going to amplify your mistake. So be sure and double check your work!

After optimizing your how, you should now be feeling like you have a little more time in your day.

4. Optimize your When

We’ve optimized what we're doing and how we're doing it. Now we need to talk about when we work.

One of my favorite ways to do this is to theme my weeks. You can generally categorize your tasks and choose a day of the week to complete one of the categories.

Let's say Monday you provide support to your team. Tuesdays could be talking with stakeholders. Wednesdays could be client meetings. Whatever theme or category that makes sense for you, just assign it to a specific day of the week.

A similar concept is to theme your days. Mornings could be for meetings, afternoons for project time. Whatever blocks you need, put them in your calendar. Just don’t put too many in one day. Give yourself larger chunks of time so you can really devote your mental energy and get in a groove.

This is also helpful to avoid something that I can guarantee is eating away at your precious time. Multitasking.

4.1. One task at a time

This is such a hard habit for people to break, but you have got to stop multitasking.

You are losing hours every single day by multitasking.

Above is a great infographic that HubSpot put together, which is a summary of this research.

40% of your thinking ability goes into switching from one task to another. This means if you reduce the number of times you switch tasks, you could get up to 40% of your day back.

Over the course of a year, 40% turns out to be 31 weeks. Imagine what you could do with all of that time!

In the US economy that equates to 650 billion dollars. That's the cost of all those interruptions.

Multitasking makes everything take longer and it makes you less good at what you’re working on. You're more likely to make mistakes and you’re going to get less done.

Email is one of the biggest ways multitasking sneaks in. Try checking your email once in the morning and again at one o'clock and that's it.

If people are trying to emergency their way into your inbox, set a boundary and determine the pace. If it's a true life or death emergency, you can create a specific way to reach you in that scenario.

All that being said, just put less on your plate. Finish your task completely, and then move on to the next thing.

5. Final thoughts

At this point you should have some great ideas on how to optimize your what, how, and when and get some more time back in your day.

If you need some extra help or guidance on ways to get out of Quadrant 1, I’d love to chat.

Book a free consultation with me or visit my Youtube channel for additional resources on everything from fundraising to DEI to strategy.

You can also download my Accountability Optimizer. It's designed to help you optimize your What, How, and When and you can get it working for you in as little as 10 minutes, even if you don’t have anyone to delegate to.

Get the Accountability Optimizer

Enter your name and email address and click

the button below to get your download.

Here are some related articles you may find interesting:

Nonprofit Leadership

If you're in nonprofit leadership or management, you know your mission statement is an integral part of running your organization. But mission statements can be tricky. Keep reading and learn how to make your mission useful and helpful to your organization.

Read →


5 Simple Steps to Achieving a High-Performing Nonprofit Board

Join Sarah Olivieri, MPS, creator of the Impact Method™️, for this one of a kind LIVE Masterclass for nonprofit leaders and board members.


The 4 Part Framework For Staffing Up

Join Sarah Olivieri, MPS, creator of the Impact Method™️, for this one of a kind LIVE Masterclass for nonprofit leaders who want to add more staff.

Our Mission

PivotGround will empower you with the tools to free up the time and brain space to focus on what matters most at your nonprofit.

© 2023 Olivieri's Inc. dba PivotGround All Rights Reserved